Tag Archives: rights and freedoms

Comment: Georgia Dream is breaking the country

>> The Georgia Drema government is pushing the country towards domestic strife, writes Hans Gutbrod.

APRIL 23 2024 (The Bulletin) — The Georgian Dream is doubling down on its draft law on “transparency of foreign influence”, directly challenging the West.

The draft law has a number of features that have led some commentators to describe it as a “repress anyone we like” law.

Critics point out that it has a sweeping scope, affecting all non-profits. The law allows for extensive intrusion by inspectors every six months and leaves plenty of room for arbitrariness. Fines for even minor deficiencies are set at a fixed 10,000 lari ($3,600), an amount that few Georgian non-profits can afford.

None of these criticisms have been answered.

If the government is concerned about how dependent much of Georgian civil society is on foreign funding, as it claims, it could make more local funding available. Instead, the Georgian Dream government pursues a repressive course, while reducing its own transparency.

No one seriously believes the stated reasons for pursuing the law. Georgia’s civil society sector is highly transparent already.

Explanations on the motives differ. Many believe the Georgian Dream is following instructions from the Kremlin, pointing to similar recent laws in Kyrgyzstan.

Others link the law with the concern that Bidzina Ivanishvili, Georgia’s oligarch-in-chief, has about potential sanctions. Is it a way of sabotaging Georgia’s European path? Demonstrators certainly seem to think so.

EU ambassadors who had hoped that the Georgian Dream could be enticed by opening the door to Europe now have to contend with a government that seems on a rampage.

The Georgian Dream, at any rate, is taking a huge bet ahead of parliamentary elections in October.

Polling suggests that 65% of people under 35 are against this law, and a similar law was abandoned last year after clashes between protesters and the police. Any sober analysis suggests that only repression can keep the government in power if it runs against the overwhelming majority of young people.

People have been protesting for days. If the law passes a second and third reading, the government will have plenty of tools for shutting down civil society. Stoking unrest and then repressing it could be the Georgian Dream’s aim.

>> Hans Gutbrod has been based in the South Caucasus since 1999. He holds a PhD in International relations from the London School of Economics.

ENDS

— This story was published in issue 565 of the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin, on April 23 2024

— Copyright the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin 2024

Threats made against Kazakh murder judge

APRIL 19 2024 (The Bulletin) — Police in Astana started investigating anonymous threats made against the judge presiding over the trial of former Kazakh economy minister Kuandyk Bishimbayev for the murder of his wife. The Supreme Court said that the threats had been left on the phone of Aizhan Kulbayeva, the judge. Bishimbayev’s trial is perhaps the most high-profile murder trial in Kazakhstan’s history.

ENDS

— This story was published in issue 565 of the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin, on April 23 2024

— Copyright the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin 2024

Armenian seperatist leader goes on hunger strike

APRIL 19 2024 (The Bulletin) — A billionaire former leader of Armenia-backed rebels in Nagorno-Karabakh has gone on hunger strike in an Azerbaijani prison, media reported. Ruben Vardanyan was arrested in September during a lightning Azerbaijani strike on Stepanakert, the rebel capital. He was the co-founder of Troika Dialog, one of Russia’s biggest investment banks, but he renounced his Russian citizenship in 2022 and moved to Stepanakert to become a leader for several months.

ENDS

— This story was published in issue 565 of the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin, on April 23 2024

— Copyright the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin 2024

Armenia strengthens domestic abuse laws

APRIL 18 2024 (The Bulletin) — Armenia’s parliament has approved new laws that toughen punishments for domestic abuse, said the New York-based Human Rights Watch. The amendments included coercion as a form of domestic abuse and labelled stalking as a crime. HRW said that more needed to be done to improve women’s rights in Armenia but that this was an important step. It also described the amendments as a move towards the West.

ENDS

— This story was published in issue 565 of the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin, on April 23 2024

— Copyright the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin 2024

Football captain backs protests

APRIL 17 2024 (The Bulletin) — The captain of the Georgian football team that qualified for the European Championships for the first time last month, joined criticism of the government’s attempts to force through a “foreign agents” law that will crimp Western-backed NGOs and media. Jaba Kankava holds near cult status in Georgia after his team defeated Greece on penalties in their final qualifying match for Euro-2024.

ENDS

— This story was published in issue 565 of the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin, on April 23 2024

— Copyright the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin 2024

Georgian MPs pass first reading of “foreign agents” law

TBILISI/APRIL 17 2024 (The Bulletin) — Georgian MPs passed the first reading of a “foreign agents” bill that will clamp down on West-backed NGOs and media. 

The bill needs to pass two more readings before it becomes law. This is expected by mid-May. The Georgian Dream government, suspected of being pro-Russia, dominates parliament. 

Thousands of people have protested against the law every day outside parliament in the centre of Tbilisi. Police used pepper spray to disperse some crowds but major clashes with protesters have not been reported, although MPs have brawled in parliament.

Last year, the Georgian Dream government abandoned a similar bill after street fights. 

ENDS

— This story was published in issue 565 of the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin, on April 23 2024

— Copyright the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin 2024

Kyrgyzstan bans TikTok

APRIL 17 2024 (The Bulletin) — Kyrgyzstan banned the Chinese social media app TikTok because lawmakers said that it was polluting young people. Its security forces, the GKNB, said that TikTok harms the “health of children, their intellect, mental, spiritual and moral development”. Kazakhstan said it is considering a similar ban.

ENDS

— This story was published in issue 565 of the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin, on April 23 2024

— Copyright the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin 2024

Tajik opposition in exile “disappear”

APRIL 16 2024 (The Bulletin) — Human rights groups said that several people linked to Group 24, an organisation banned in Tajikistan have disappeared from Lithuania, Poland and Turkey over the past few weeks. Human Rights Watch and the Norwegian Helsinki Committee accused Tajikistan of orchestrating a secret extradition project against Group 24 members. Group 24 is a political movement opposed to Tajik Pres. Emomali Rakhmon and has been labelled a terror group by the Tajik government.

ENDS

— This story was published in issue 565 of the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin, on April 23 2024

— Copyright the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin 2024

Trial of former economy minsiter for murder is an opportunity for Kazakhstan

>> The trial of a former economy minister in Kazakhstan for murdering his wife is a chance to improve the country’s shaming domestic abuse record, says James Kilner

APRIL 15 2024 (The Bulletin) –It’s not just the law’s view of domestic violence in Kazakhstan that has stained the country’s reputation. Attitudes need to change too.

It has taken the heinous murder by Kuandyk Bishimbayev of his wife last year to force Kazakh lawmakers to toughen punishment around domestic violence, but these laws will be no good if they are undermined by a system that doesn’t want women to speak out.

The UN has  demanded change. It said that 62,000 women in Kazakhstan reported abuse last year, although it has also said that the real number of victims is much higher.

Women are not encouraged to speak out in Kazakhstan’s strongly patriarchal society. 

They are expected to accept their beatings and to remain quiet and this means that progress on improving women’s rights is stunted. It’s one thing toughening punishment for men who abuse their wives or children, it is quite another to create a culture where women feel safe enough to speak out.

The case of Bishimbayev is a case in point. 

He is an ugly, corrupt and pathetic man who took his frustrations out on the women in his life by beating them. He hasn’t been convicted yet of the murder of his wife, Saltanat Nukenova, in November at a restaurant owned by a family member – but evidence is mounting. 

CCTV film shows him hitting Nukenova that evening. Her lifeless body lay on the floor of the restaurant for hours while Bishimbayev callously schemed over how to shift blame. 

He ordered the CCTV film to be wiped clean and for a chauffeur to drive Nukenova’s smartphone around Astana in the hope that it would fool people into thinking that she had been alive.

None of it appears to have worked. Bishimbayev’s only hope of avoiding years in prison appears to be pressuring the judge and using his privileged position as a member of the Kazakh elite to push for a light sentence. 

He’s pulled the trick before. In 2027, shortly after resigning as Kazakhstan’s economy minister, he was sent to prison for a decade for corruption but managed to walk free after only three years. 

Now, Kazakhstan has a chance to right these wrongs. It needs to sort out its terrible domestic abuse record, setting an example for the rest of the region, and it needs to imprison Bishimbayev for a long time.

ENDS

— This story was published in issue 564 of the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin, on April 15 2024

— Copyright the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin 2024

Soros Foundation quits Kyrgyzstan because of “foreign agents” law

BISHKEK/APRIL 15 2024 (The Bulletin) — The Soros Foundation quit Kyrgyzstan after 31 years because of a new Kremlin-inspired law that gives the government intrusive powers over Western-backed NGOs and media.

Its Open Society New York-based parent company said that Kyrgyzstan’s “foreign agents” law, which came into effect this month, would have “negative consequences” for civil society.

“We deeply regret that the organisation’s activities will no longer be able to continue and that the new repressive law will lead to civil society operating in conditions of uncertainty and fear,” said Binaifer Novroji, the Open Society president.

Kyrgyzstan said that it needed the new law to improve transparency and tighten national security but activists said that it will be used to crush dissenting media and NGOs. Analysts said the law highlights the influence of the Kremlin despite its war in Ukraine. Russia introduced a “foreign agents” law in 2012.

Civil society in Kyrgyzstan has been largely reliant on Western support to grow. The Soros Foundation in Bishkek said that it had invested $115m in the country, mainly in education and social issues.

“The extremely vague content of the concept of ‘political activity’ leads to negative consequences or unforeseen risks for both the Fund and its partners,” it said.

Other Western-backed NGOs have said they are also considering retreating from Kyrgyzstan after the new law was passed.

ENDS

— This story was published in issue 565 of the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin, on April 23 2024

— Copyright the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin 2024