Tag Archives: politics

Comment: Uzbekistan’s not-so-free election

DEC. 27 2019 (The Bulletin) — Uzbekistan and its leader, Shavkat Mirziyoyev, have a lot to live up to in 2020. The Economist’s ‘Country of the year’, it feels like Mr Mirziyoyev has done the easy bit in Uzbekistan. He has taken the low hanging fruit from the tree and ripped into it.

I’m talking, of course, about his economic reforms that have been lauded across newspapers across the globe ahead of a parliamentary election on Dec. 22. He has improved conditions for private businesses to operate, he has pulled together Uzbekistan’s previously complicated exchange rate mechanisms and he has encouraged foreign investors to build factories and create jobs.

Perhaps most striking is the shift to being tourist friendly. In the early 2000s, the trademark reaction from Uzbek police and border guards when you wanted to cross into the country was gruff indignation. Now, it is a cheery hello. This year I made two land crossings into Uzbekistan, one from Shymkent in Kazakhstan and another from Osh in Kyrgyzstan. Neither could have been easier and none of the officials more charming.

And the tourism impact is partly behind this economic boom.

There are more Western tourists in Uzbekistan now than ever before. The infrastructure is still catching up with this expansion but it will get there. Uzbeks are natural hosts and want to make their guests welcome.

But talk around the election of genuine political changes is misguided. Mirziyoyev is no more likely to relinquish power as his predecessor, Islam Karimov. He has shown his ruthlessness by imprisoning senior and potentially troublesome members of the former regime already. All the power is concentrated into his hands. Parliament is there to rubber stamp his decisions and this latest election highlighted these traits.

Uzbek officials are playing a wily game. As they shift Uzbekistan into the spotlight and take their seats at the various international organisations that Karimov denied to them for so long, people will start asking questions about not only the state of the economy and business but also about political plurality, free speech, the media and the ability to object. By carefully stage managing this parliamentary election, with five political parties and a leaders’ debate on television they have given the impression, to some, that Uzbekistan is set for genuine far-reaching political reforms.

This is extremely doubtful, a scepticism highlighted by a parliamentary motion to toughen sentences for unsanctioned demonstrations.
Mirziyoyev faces a daunting 2020.

ENDS

— This story was first published in issue 432 of the weekly Bulletin on Dec. 27 2019

Copyright owned by the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin

US warns Georgia that it must improve its commitment to democracy

TBILISI/DEC. 24 2019 (The Bulletin) — The United States told Georgia’s government that it had to improve its commitment to democracy after weeks of anti-government protests and a counter-demonstration organised by the Georgian Dream coalition.

The intervention into the domestic politics of the US’ most loyal regional ally will be seen as a blow to Georgia leader Bidzina Ivanishvili, the country’s richest man and the architect of the Georgian Dream coalition.

In a statement, the US State Department said that it supported dialogue between opposition groups and the government.

“We urge the Georgian government to reinforce its commitment to the principles of democracy, individual liberty, and rule of law by ensuring that its judicial and prosecutorial system is free of political bias,” it said.

Rights groups have said that the Georgian Dream government has started to use the courts to pursue personal vendettas, allegations that the Georgian Dream government has denied. Opposition groups also accuse the Georgian Dream government of trying to interfere with the appointment of Supreme Court judges.

But a senior Georgian Dream official brushed off the implied criticism in the US statement.
“Anyone who can read this statement knows very well that it is actually supportive,” said Irakli Kobakhidze, the Georgian Dream executive secretary.

Protesters have demonstrated since MPs voted last month against backing plans to introduce proportional representation at next year’s parliamentary election. The government, though, in an attempted to compromise has said that the number of MPs elected by a first-past-the-post system will be reduced at the election.

ENDS

— This story was first published in issue 432 of the weekly Bulletin on Dec. 27 2019

Copyright owned by the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin

People vote in Azerbaijan’s municipal elections

DEC. 23 2019 (The Bulletin) — Around a third of Azerbaijan’s population voted in municipal elections seen as a warm-up to a parliamentary election in February. For the first time since 2005 some genuine opposition activists took part in the election, although many others boycotted it complaining that the terms and conditions of the campaign were weighted against them. Analysts have said that ordinary Azerbaijanis are increasingly frustrated with the economic stagnation and corruption. The results of the election have not yet been announced.

ENDS

— This story was first published in issue 432 of the weekly Bulletin on Dec. 27 2019

Copyright owned by the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin

Monitors say fraud blights Uzbekistan’s ‘freest’ election

TASHKENT/DEC. 22 2019 (The Bulletin) — Uzbekistan held the first round of a parliamentary election dubbed by officials as its most free election ever, although observers said that there were violations in the one-sided contest.

Under the slogan “New Uzbekistan – new elections”, a slogan that appeared to be aimed at the watching international audience rather than at ordinary Uzbeks, millions of people voted in the first election since Shavkat Mirziyoyev won a vote in December 2016 to rubber-stamp his coronation as Uzbekistan’s president.

He took over from the repressive Islam Karimov, who died of a heart attack in September 2016, and has focused on opening up the country, economically at least, since.

But, despite the hype around the election, the choice was limited for the 150-seat parliament between five parties that all broadly support Mr Mirziyoyev. Live TV debates between the candidates, a new phenomenon, were staid and scripted.

This was a point acknowledged by the OSCE’s election monitoring unit, ODHIR.

“Improvements to Uzbekistan’s election law and greater acceptance of freedom of expression are to be welcomed, but did not offset the absence of opposition parties, a continuing lack of respect for fundamental rights, and some serious irregularities on election day,” it said in a statement.

Some positive aspects to the election were also highlighted.

Tana de Zulueta, Head of ODIHR’s election observation mission, said: “Independent voices are growing in number and strength, and there is a new sense of freedom. This is very much to be welcomed.”

Mr Mirziyoyev’s version of liberalism has, so far, focused on the economy, freeing up people to trade with neighbouring countries and boosting tourism and construction which has fuelled an economic boom.

Analysts have said that to genuinely transform politics and divest power away from the presidency is a far harder task.

A second round of voting is due next month to complete Uzbekistan’s parliamentary election.
ENDS

— This story was first published in issue 432 of the weekly Bulletin on Dec. 27 2019

Copyright owned by the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin

Uzbek bill proposes tougher new sentences for unsanctioned protests

DEC. 17 2019 (The Bulletin) — Ahead of a parliamentary election on Dec. 22, lawmakers in Uzbekistan submitted a draft bill that called on punishments for unsanctioned demonstrations to be tightened, Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty reported. According to RFE/RL, if the law is approved it will impose a 10-year prison sentence for people organising an unapproved demonstration. This year, there has been a spate of small-scale protests in Uzbekistan, mainly triggered by price rises and a lack of gas and electricity.

ENDS

— This story was first published in issue 432 of the weekly Bulletin on Dec. 27 2019

Copyright owned by the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin

New action movie targets dictator in ‘Turgistan’

DEC. 13 2019 (The Bulletin) — Netflix released a new action film about the overthrow of a dictator from a fictional country called Turgistan, a fantasy land that appears to be based on Turkmenistan.

In the movie ‘6 Underground’, a US tech billionaire launches a privately-funded mission to overthrow Rovach Alimov, president of Turgistan. Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty said that as well as the name, scenes and language used by people in the film make it appear set in Turkmenistan. Central Asia has already featured a handful of times in spoof television programmes and films.

The 2006 film featuring fictional Kazakh reporter Borat caused Kazakhstan’s government years of grief and in 2013 the made-up state of Tazbekistan was the focus of a BBC comedy called ‘Ambassadors’.

ENDS

— This story was first published in issue 432 of the weekly Bulletin on Dec. 27 2019

Copyright owned by the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin

Nazarbayev given honorary Central Asia role

DEC. 6 (The Bulletin) — Kazakhstan’s former president, Nursultan Nazarbayev, was named honorary chairman of the Consultative Meeting of the Heads of State of Central Asia, a talking shop for the region’s leaders, at its meeting in Tashkent. Mr Nazarbayev said immediately after quitting the presidency in March this year that he wanted to maintain a role in Kazakh politics. He also sees himself as the elder statesman of Central Asia, a position this title cements.
ENDS

— This story was first published in issue 431 of the weekly Bulletin on Dec. 9 2019

Copyright owned by the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin

Georgian Dream supporters rally against opposition

DEC. 2 (The Bulletin) — Supporters of the Georgian Dream government coalition rallied in central Tbilisi against anti-government protesters who have been demonstrating since the end of last month when parliament voted against introducing election reforms called for by the opposition. Analysts are increasingly worried that street-level politics has become the norm in Georgia.
ENDS

— This story was first published in issue 431 of the weekly Bulletin on Dec. 9 2019

Copyright owned by the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin

Armenia wants to arrest former Prosecutor-General

DEC. 3 (The Bulletin) — Prosecutors in Armenia put out an arrest warrant for Gevorg Kostanyan, Armenia’s former Prosecutor-General, in connection with the ongoing trials of several former top officials, including former president Robert Kocharyan, for the shooting dead of 14 people at a post-election demonstration in 2008. Mr Kostanyan now lives in Moscow. Critics of the prosecution of the former senior officials said that the government of PM Nikol Pashinyan was pursuing political vendettas.
ENDS

— This story was first published in issue 431 of the weekly Bulletin on Dec. 9 2019

Copyright owned by the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin

Kyrgyz court jails two former PMs

DEC. 6 (The Bulletin) — A court in Kyrgyzstan sentenced two former PMs to jail for corruption in a case that some analysts have said highlights how political vendettas are played out in the region. Sapar Iskarov, PM in 2017-18, and Jantoro Satybaldiyev were given 15 years and 7-1/2 years in prison for corruption linked to the $400m refit of a power station near Bishkek by a Chinese company.
ENDS

— This story was first published in issue 431 of the weekly Bulletin on Dec. 9 2019

Copyright owned by the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin