Tag Archives: media freedom

Comment: Georgia Dream is breaking the country

>> The Georgia Drema government is pushing the country towards domestic strife, writes Hans Gutbrod.

APRIL 23 2024 (The Bulletin) — The Georgian Dream is doubling down on its draft law on “transparency of foreign influence”, directly challenging the West.

The draft law has a number of features that have led some commentators to describe it as a “repress anyone we like” law.

Critics point out that it has a sweeping scope, affecting all non-profits. The law allows for extensive intrusion by inspectors every six months and leaves plenty of room for arbitrariness. Fines for even minor deficiencies are set at a fixed 10,000 lari ($3,600), an amount that few Georgian non-profits can afford.

None of these criticisms have been answered.

If the government is concerned about how dependent much of Georgian civil society is on foreign funding, as it claims, it could make more local funding available. Instead, the Georgian Dream government pursues a repressive course, while reducing its own transparency.

No one seriously believes the stated reasons for pursuing the law. Georgia’s civil society sector is highly transparent already.

Explanations on the motives differ. Many believe the Georgian Dream is following instructions from the Kremlin, pointing to similar recent laws in Kyrgyzstan.

Others link the law with the concern that Bidzina Ivanishvili, Georgia’s oligarch-in-chief, has about potential sanctions. Is it a way of sabotaging Georgia’s European path? Demonstrators certainly seem to think so.

EU ambassadors who had hoped that the Georgian Dream could be enticed by opening the door to Europe now have to contend with a government that seems on a rampage.

The Georgian Dream, at any rate, is taking a huge bet ahead of parliamentary elections in October.

Polling suggests that 65% of people under 35 are against this law, and a similar law was abandoned last year after clashes between protesters and the police. Any sober analysis suggests that only repression can keep the government in power if it runs against the overwhelming majority of young people.

People have been protesting for days. If the law passes a second and third reading, the government will have plenty of tools for shutting down civil society. Stoking unrest and then repressing it could be the Georgian Dream’s aim.

>> Hans Gutbrod has been based in the South Caucasus since 1999. He holds a PhD in International relations from the London School of Economics.

ENDS

— This story was published in issue 565 of the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin, on April 23 2024

— Copyright the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin 2024

Georgian MPs pass first reading of “foreign agents” law

TBILISI/APRIL 17 2024 (The Bulletin) — Georgian MPs passed the first reading of a “foreign agents” bill that will clamp down on West-backed NGOs and media. 

The bill needs to pass two more readings before it becomes law. This is expected by mid-May. The Georgian Dream government, suspected of being pro-Russia, dominates parliament. 

Thousands of people have protested against the law every day outside parliament in the centre of Tbilisi. Police used pepper spray to disperse some crowds but major clashes with protesters have not been reported, although MPs have brawled in parliament.

Last year, the Georgian Dream government abandoned a similar bill after street fights. 

ENDS

— This story was published in issue 565 of the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin, on April 23 2024

— Copyright the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin 2024

Kyrgyzstan bans TikTok

APRIL 17 2024 (The Bulletin) — Kyrgyzstan banned the Chinese social media app TikTok because lawmakers said that it was polluting young people. Its security forces, the GKNB, said that TikTok harms the “health of children, their intellect, mental, spiritual and moral development”. Kazakhstan said it is considering a similar ban.

ENDS

— This story was published in issue 565 of the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin, on April 23 2024

— Copyright the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin 2024

Soros Foundation quits Kyrgyzstan because of “foreign agents” law

BISHKEK/APRIL 15 2024 (The Bulletin) — The Soros Foundation quit Kyrgyzstan after 31 years because of a new Kremlin-inspired law that gives the government intrusive powers over Western-backed NGOs and media.

Its Open Society New York-based parent company said that Kyrgyzstan’s “foreign agents” law, which came into effect this month, would have “negative consequences” for civil society.

“We deeply regret that the organisation’s activities will no longer be able to continue and that the new repressive law will lead to civil society operating in conditions of uncertainty and fear,” said Binaifer Novroji, the Open Society president.

Kyrgyzstan said that it needed the new law to improve transparency and tighten national security but activists said that it will be used to crush dissenting media and NGOs. Analysts said the law highlights the influence of the Kremlin despite its war in Ukraine. Russia introduced a “foreign agents” law in 2012.

Civil society in Kyrgyzstan has been largely reliant on Western support to grow. The Soros Foundation in Bishkek said that it had invested $115m in the country, mainly in education and social issues.

“The extremely vague content of the concept of ‘political activity’ leads to negative consequences or unforeseen risks for both the Fund and its partners,” it said.

Other Western-backed NGOs have said they are also considering retreating from Kyrgyzstan after the new law was passed.

ENDS

— This story was published in issue 565 of the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin, on April 23 2024

— Copyright the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin 2024

Police raid Bishkek bars

APRIL 14 2024 (The Bulletin) — Police in Bishkek raided two popular Bishkek bars, Ailan and Plur.Plur.Plur, and detained several people for drug tests, witnesses said. Analysts have said that the raid may be linked to the Kyrgyz government’s drive to clamp down on liberal segments of society. It has introduced a “foreign agents” law to monitor more closely NGOs and media that received funding from the West.

ENDS

— This story was published in issue 564 of the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin, on April 15 2024

— Copyright the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin 2024

Thousands of Georgians protest against “foreign agents” law

TBILISI/APRIL 11 2024 (The Bulletin) — — Thousands of people protested in Tbilisi against the Georgian Dream government’s attempt to re-impose a Kremlin-inspired “foreign agents” law.

Its move to impose the law a year after riots forced it to abandon its first attempt came as Kyrgyzstan adopted its own version of the law that crimps Western-funded NGOs and media groups.

“This is a Russian law,” said one of the protesters gathered in central Tbilisi. Many waved the blue and gold flag of the European Commission and accused the Georgian Dream of being a Kremlin stooge.

Although Georgia fought a war against Russia in 2008 over its breakaway territories, the Georgian Dream has kept Georgia officially neutral over the Russia-Ukraine war and has even improved some business and education-related ties with the Kremlin

Salome Zurabishvili, Georgia’s pro-West president, called the “foreign agents” law a betrayal of Georgia’s newly won EU candidate status.

“This is a Russian dream,” she said in a dig at the Georgian Dream’s name

The EU said that the “foreign agents” bill was “incompatible” with Georgia’s push to join the bloc and Freedom House, a US human rights group, said that Georgia was becoming a “semi-consolidated authoritarian regime”.

The Georgian Dream has said that the law is needed to reduce foreign influence in its politics and to promote funding transparency. It also said that opposition parties had misled people last year by misrepresenting the law to score political points, a charge rejected by opposition leaders.

Opposition activists have accused the Kremlin of using its 2012 law to stamp out dissent.

Kyrgyzstan has also been criticised for adopting its own version of the “foreign agents” law.

“The legislation that restricts civil society organisations’ ability to operate freely could have a negative impact on the Kyrgyz society and their cooperation with international partners,” said the EU.

ENDS

— This story was published in issue 564 of the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin, on April 15 2024

— Copyright the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin 2024

Attackers firebomb Kazakh journalist’s car

JAN. 13 2023 (The Bulletin) — Unknown attackers firebombed a car belonging to Kazakh journalist Dinara Yegeubaeva on the anniversary of anti-government protests across Kazakhstan. Ms Yegeubaeva interviewed dozens of protesters who were detained and tortured by the police and broadcast them on social media channels. She had received several threats before her car was attacked.

ENDS

— This story was published in issue 532 of the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin, on Jan. 16 2023

— Copyright the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin 2023

Kazakh police arrest investigative journalist

DEC. 19 2022 (The Bulletin) — Police in Kazakhstan arrested investigative journalist Mikhail Kozachkov for allegedly taking a bribe from a crime boss to smear and blackmail business leaders. His supporters have said that he is being targeted in retaliation for his investigations into corruption in the police. They also said that Mr Kozachkov is being denied proper legal assistance.

ENDS

— This story was published in issue 532 of the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin, on Jan. 16 2023

— Copyright the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin 2023

Georgian Dream opponents say government tries to smear reporter

JULY 19 2021 (The Bulletin) — Opponents of the Georgian Dream government accused it of trying to smear Alexander Lasharava, a TV cameraman killed this month by anti-gay rights protesters, by accusing him of being a heroin user after traces of an opiate were found in his blood. Lasharava’s supporters said that he was given morphine by a hospital before he was discharged. He died at home. His death sparked several days of anti-government protests.

ENDS

— This story was published in issue 493 of the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin, on July 22 2021

— Copyright the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin 2021

Uzbek journalists accuse official of beating them up

TASHKENT/JUNE 7 2021 (The Bulletin) — Concerns over the Uzbek authorities’ commitment to media freedom have once again been raised after journalists covering the trial in Andijan of three reporters accused of libel said that they had been beaten up by the son of a local official.

This year, the Uzbek government passed a law that bans criticism of Pres. Shavkat Mirziyoyev ahead of an election in October. This preceded the arrest of several journalists and bloggers, considered to be anti-government.

Western media freedom groups have become increasingly sceptical of statements by Pres. Mirziyoyev, who took over from the reclusive Islam Karimov in 2016, that he wants a more free society and open society in Uzbekistan.

ENDS

— This story was published in issue 487 of the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin, on June 9 2021

— Copyright the Central Asia & South Caucasus Bulletin 2021